If anyone cares, (doubt it due to this thread's overwhelming response)
I pulled the rotors and had them turned.
The nice guy at O'Reilly turned them for free. :afro: When I went to pick them up, he asked me if I paid. I said I didn't and he said, don't worry about it and he normally didn't charge to turn rotors.
As I was reassembling it, I noticed the rotor was rubbing the splash shield. (Doh!)
Bent it back, scuffed the pads up a bit and bedded in the brakes again. Problem solved. I think the problem was that damnable splash shield Glad I didn't pay to turn the rotors.